What's Your Story?
| Phantom Wealth Casino Economy | Real Wealth Living Earth Economy |
Defining Slogan | The one with the most toys wins | We all do better when we all do better |
Human Nature | We humans are by nature motivated to pursue individual self-interest and material acquisition. Cooperation in service to some greater community good is contrary to our nature. | We humans are complex beings of many possibilities. The mature consciousness finds joy in cooperation, caring, and service to others. Greed, violence, and extreme individualism are symptoms of psychological dysfunction. |
Money | Money is wealth and those who make money are creating new wealth that ultimately trickles down to benefit us all. | Money is a mere number, an accounting chit. Those who make money unassociated with the creation of anything of real value are engaged in a form of theft. |
Markets | Free from taxes and government regulation, the market rewards in direct proportion to individual contribution and turns the pursuit of individual financial advantage into greater wealth and well-being for all. | Markets work best when within a framework of rules and values that reflect the community interest. Markets that celebrate and reward psychological dysfunction are destructive of community values and well-being. |
Community Interest | The community interest is a simple aggregation of individual interests. We all do best when we each seek to maximize our individual financial gain. | Strong caring communities are essential to our individual and collective happiness, security, and general well-being. We all do better when we look out for one another and invest collectively in community and environmental health. |
Rules | Our economic system is sound. Deficiencies are best resolved by eliminating distorting rules and taxes. | Our fatally flawed economic system undermines our well-being and threatens our survival as a species. We must replace it with a new system based on community values and valid assumptions. |
System Alternatives | The only alternative to the excess of global capitalism is the oppressive and unproductive state tyranny of socialism/communism. | Capitalism and communism both centralize and concentrate economic power in unaccountable institutions. The better option is a system of properly regulated locally rooted regional economies. |
Indicators | Growth in Gross Domestic Product (GDP) is an indicator of economic progress and growth in the total wealth and well-being of society | GDP is a measure of the economic cost of producing a given level of well-being. Economic performance is better assessed against nonfinancial indicators of the health of our children, families, communities, and natural systems. |
These are two starkly contrasting economic stories. Which has the greater currency in the public culture? Which, by your experience, is the more valid? What’s your story? | ||
Note that this page may be copied and used as an effective group discussion exercise.